Introduction
The Torah records the prohibition of cooking meat with milk in the following verses:
- “You shall bring to the house of Hashem, your G-d the choicest first fruits of your land (Israel). You shall not cook a kid (גדי) in its mother’s milk (Exodus 23:19).”
- “You shall bring to the house of Hashem, your G-d the choicest first fruits of your land (Israel). You shall not cook a kid (גדי) in its mother’s milk G-d. You shall not cook a kid in its mother’s milk (Exodus 34:26).” This verse is identical to the above verse.
- You shall not eat any animal that was not ritually slaughtered. You may give it to the gentile in your cities or sell it to a foreigner. You are a holy people to Hashem, your G-d. You shall not cook a kid in its mother’s milk (Deuteronomy 14:21).”
The reader may ask, “Why does the Torah repeat this prohibition 3 times and in the same wording for the above 2 verses?” The Talmud (Chullin 115b) explains that there are the following prohibitions for meat and milk mixtures:
- Consumption.
- Benefit – for example feeding to one’s animal.
- Cooking – even if the food belongs to a gentile.
The Talmud (ibid. 113a) also notes that the 3 fold repetition of the word kid (גדי) comes to exclude:
- Undomesticated kosher animal (e.g. deer).
- Fowl.
- Non kosher animal.
It is interesting to note that these prohibitions do not apply to Noahides.
Analysis
Rationales
Although the Torah does not provide a rationale for these prohibitions many Torah commentators have provided explanations. For the sake of brevity the author lists some of the well known explanations:
- Maimonides (Guide for the Perplexed Chapter 48) – idolatry or unhealthy.
- Sefer HaChinuch (Mitzvah #92 and 113) – forbidden mixtures.
- Zohar (2:124b-125a) – negative forces.
- Ibn Ezra (Exodus 23:19) – cruelty.
- Rashbam (ibid.) – gluttony.
Maimonides – Idolatry
Maimonides (ibid.) writes, “Meat boiled in milk is undoubtedly gross food and makes one overfull. However I think that most probably it is also prohibited because it is somehow connected with idolatry, forming perhaps part of a service or festival of the heathen. I find a support for this view because the Torah mentions the prohibition twice after the commandment concerning the festivals. The Torah states: Three times in the year all your males shall appear before the L-rd, Hashem (Exodus 23:17 and similar wording in 34:23). This implies that when you come before Me (Hashem) on your festivals, do not seethe your meat in the same manner as the heathens.”
In a similar vein Rabbi Obadiah ben Jacob Sforno, of 15th to 16th centuries Italy, explains in his commentary to the Torah (Exodus 23:19) that some idolaters believed by cooking a kid in its mother’s milk would increase crop yield. The Torah dispels this notion by prohibiting this practice. On the contrary one should bring first fruits to the temple to receive divine blessing of bounty.
Sefer HaChinuch – Forbidden Mixtures
By contrast the Sefer HaChinuch explains this prohibition in terms of forbidden mixtures. He reasons that Hashem created a natural order for the world and mixtures prohibited by the Torah spiritually upset this order. Therefore the Torah prohibits cooking meat with milk even if the person has no intention of eating this mixture. Consequently he does not need to accept the reason that this food is unwholesome for consumption.
Zohar – Negative Forces
The Zohar similarly focuses on forbidden mixtures and explains that this prohibition involves negative forces in a mystical sense. The mother represents the Shechinah which acts as a protecting and nurturing mother of the Israelites. By contrast the kid (גדי) represents the negative forces of Esau because he is compared to the goat through an association of Hebrew words. A grown goat is called (שעיר) in Hebrew and the hirsute Esau is called שער (e.g. Genesis 25:21 and 27:11). In addition the land of Esau is called שעיר (e.g. ibid. 32:4). The mixture of meat (representing death or violence) with milk (life and nurturing) may be injurious to the soul of an Israelite (ibid. 1:125a) and even affect a child conceived after consuming this mixture (ibid. 1:125b).
The Zohar (3:41b) notes that this explanation of negative forces of the goat must be nuanced because the goat is a kosher animal (viz. it has split hooves and chews its cud). Therefore the Zohar explains that these negative forces are external to the goat and are dispelled through sacrificial rites (e.g. scapegoat on the Day of Atonement). They are invoked by the meat and milk prohibition.
Although the prohibition applies to any of the kosher domesticated mammals the Torah alludes to these forces through the word גדי.
Abraham Ibn Ezra – Cruelty
The Torah commentator Abraham Ibn Ezra, of 12th century Spain and Italy, explains that eating milk with meat is a symbol of cruelty because at a literal level the prohibition involves consuming the meat of the child with the milk of the mother. He compares this prohibition to that of slaughtering a mother animal and its offspring on the same day (Leviticus 22:28) which is also a symbol of cruelty (i.e. symbolically destroying a family).
Rashbam – Gluttony
The Torah commentator (Rashbam), a grandson of Rashi, explains that eating meat with milk is a sign of gluttony because at a literal level the prohibition entails consuming the meat of the child with milk of the mother. He also compares this prohibition to that of slaughtering a mother animal and its offspring on the same day (Leviticus 22:28) which is an indication of overconsumption. He explains that this verse appears in the context of the festivals because the Israelites would eat much meat at that time.
Method of Analysis
In the opinion of the author the following techniques aid in explaining a rationale for these prohibitions:
- Text of actual verses.
- Context of verses (i.e. preceding and following).
- Similar prohibitions.
- Details in Halacha.
Text of Verses
First Fruits
As mentioned above the Torah cites 3 verses for the meat and milk prohibition. The first 2 verses mention the mitzvah of the bringing the first fruits to the temple which prompts the question, “What is the connection of this mitzvah to the prohibition of meat and milk?” There are many answers to this question and for the sake of brevity the author will cite the following:
- Punishment (Targum Yonatan ben Uziel on Exodus 23:19) – If the Israelites do not bring their first fruits to the priests then Hashem will punish them with a failure in the crops, based upon the principle of measure for measure (Sotah 8b). Specifically the Targum translates the expression “cook a kid its mother’s milk” allegorically as Hashem cooking (destroying) the grain in the stalks.
- Timing (Rashbam ibid.) – The Israelites brought first fruits to the temple before the pilgrim festivals. During these festivals the Israelites would enjoy meat hence the prohibition of eating meat with milk.
- Protection (Zohar 1:125a) – The Zohar explains that the mitzvah of bringing first fruits entails a recitation of a passage from the Torah (Deuteronomy 26:5-10) describing Hashem’s protection and deliverance from Laban and the Egyptians. In this manner the Zohar links this mitzvah of protection from the negative forces which result from those transgressing the prohibition of eating meat with milk. Hence the Zohar provides an important lesson in Torah interpretation with regard to allusions. The link to different mitzvoth may relate to an aspect of the mitzvah (e.g. the declaration and not necessarily the fruit itself).
- Closeness to Hashem – In the opinion of the author the juxtaposition of these two mitzvoth relates to closeness to Hashem. The mitzvah of bringing first fruits to the temple is a means to support the priests and draw close to Hashem. For example, the Mishna (Bikkurim 1:8) states that if a person lost his first fruits on the way to the temple he must replace them. However the next Mishna explains that if a person brought the fruit to the temple courtyard and then were lost or stolen before giving them to the priest he does not need to replace them because bringing the fruit is sufficient.
Appendix 1 discusses the mitzvah of selecting the first fruits and bringing them to the temple in Jerusalem especially in terms of closeness to Hashem.
Pursuit of Holiness
The third verse (Deuteronomy 14:21) clearly indicates that the prohibition of eating meat with milk relates to the holiness of the Israelites. The verse follows, “You shall not eat any animal (kosher or non-kosher) that was not ritually slaughtered. You may give it to the gentile in your cities or sell it to a foreigner. You are a holy people to Hashem, your G-d. You shall not cook a kid in its mother’s milk (Deuteronomy 14:21).”
The Zohar (2:125a and 3:41b) explains that eating non-kosher food renders an Israelite spiritually impure which is more severe than ritually impurity because eating prohibited food is absorbed into the body. By contrast ritual impurity results from contact with the source of impurity and does not penetrate the body. In addition immersion in a mikvah removes ritual impurity. However there is not a direct means of removing spiritual impurity caused by consuming prohibited foods.
The Torah emphasizes that this prohibition is unique to the Israelites. The first part of the verse refers to a kosher animal that either died naturally or was not slaughtered properly. Hence it is similar to the prohibition of meat with milk in that both prohibitions involve a kosher animal.
Context of Verses
In addition to the above verses, one may find a rationale for the prohibition of meat with milk from the verse that precede and follow these 3 verses. The Mishna in Avot 1:2, states “On 3 things the world stands – on Torah study, service to Hashem, and generous deeds.” Rabbi Obadiah of Bertinoro, of 15th century Italy, on this Mishna explains that service to Hashem relates to temple offerings. Generous deeds involves all mitzvoth between man and man (Tiferet Yisrael by Rabbi Israel Lipschitz ibid.).
Hence the verses that precede or follow the 3 verses of the prohibition of meat and milk follow this pattern:
- Torah study – The verse (Exodus 34:27) which follows the prohibition of meat with milk states that Hashem said to Moses, “Write these words (of Torah) for yourself, for according to these words I have formed a covenant with you and Israel.”
- Service to Hashem – The verses before the prohibition of meat and milk in Exodus relate to the pilgrim festivals and related offerings to Hashem (ibid. 23:17-18 and 34:23-25).
- Mitzvoth between man and man – The verse following this prohibition in Deuteronomy (ibid. 14:22) relates to tithing which is a mitzvah between man and man.
In addition to these 3 components the Torah alludes to the following contexts for the meat and milk prohibition:
- Pursuit of Holiness – The verses, Deuteronomy 14:3-20, preceding the meat and milk prohibition refer to kosher and non kosher animals (cattle, fish, and fowl). In turn the Torah indicates that these dietary laws promote holiness as the verse (ibid. 2) states, “For you are a holy people (Israelites) to Hashem your G-d. Hashem has chosen you to be a treasured people for Him, out of all the nations upon the earth.”
- Separation from Hashem – the verse that follows the first mention of the meat and milk prohibition (Exodus 23:20) speaks of a separation of the Israelites from Hashem. The verse follows, “Behold, I (Hashem) am sending an angel before you to protect you on the way and bring you to the place that I have prepared (land of Israel).” At a literal level the context of this verse is unclear because why would Hashem send an angel and not lead the Israelites directly? The Midrash (Exodus Rabbah 32:3) explains that this verse prophetically indicates Hashem’s displeasure of the Israelites after worshipping the golden calf. However Moses pleaded with Hashem to directly lead the Israelites and Hashem agreed (Exodus 33:17 and 34:10) because Moses would lead the people with Hashem’s help.
Hence by refraining from eating meat with milk, one is enabled to perform these mitzvoth with a greater connection to Hashem.
Similar Prohibitions
Although the Torah (Leviticus 19:19) cites several prohibitions of mixing different items (e.g. crossbreeding animals, seeds in a field, grafting of different species of trees, wearing a garment of wool and linen) the results of the mixture are permitted to use. In the case of the first two prohibitions only the act of mixing is prohibited. For the last prohibition only the wearing of the garment is prohibited but not its manufacture.
Hence the closest prohibition to cooking meat with milk is the prohibition of planting mixed seeds in a vineyard because both prohibitions share the same characteristics:
- Initially both items permissible.
- Prohibition for preparation (cooking for the former and planting for the latter).
- Mixture is prohibited to eat.
- Mixture is prohibited for benefit.
The Sefer HaChinuch lists the following prohibitions, which are punishable by lashes, concerning mixed seeds in a vineyard:
- Planting – two different types of seeds in a vineyard (Mitzvah #548).
- Benefit – eating or selling the resultant produce (Mitzvah #549).
This source provides a rationale for both mitzvoth which in turn relates to the prohibition of meat with milk. The prohibition of planting relates to the importance of the seeds typically wheat and barley in a vineyard and the need to separate them. The prohibition of benefit relates to temptation of wine which can lead to drunkenness and therefore the Torah separate needs (i.e. essential grain products) and from wants (i.e. the pleasure of wine).
Differences
However there are differences because the prohibition of mixed seeds only applies:
- To products that grow from the ground.
- In Israel from a biblical standpoint.
By contrast the prohibition of meat and milk applies in and out of Israel and both products do not grow from the ground.
Hence in the opinion of the author one must combine the comparison to forbidden mixtures to one of the other rationales to obtain a complete picture.
Appendix 2 provides the details of the prohibition of mixing seeds in a vineyard.
Talmud
The Talmud (Hullin) analyzes the above verses to determine the extent of this prohibition as follows:
- Kid.
- Mother
Kid
Although the Torah only mentions a kid or young goat (גדי) the Talmud (ibid. 113a-b) shows that the Hebrew word גדי means any young kosher domesticated animal. If the Torah specifically indicates a young goat then the word עזים (goats) (Genesis 38:17) or העזים (the goats) as (ibid. 27:16 and 38:20) is used.
Mother
The Talmud (ibid. 114a) asks, “How does one know that that the mother mentioned in this prohibition is not literal and refers to any kosher domesticated animal?” The Talmud (ibid.) answers that the second of the 3 verses comes to include these animals and the mother herself as meat.
Here the Talmud provides an important lesson in Torah interpretation, namely the Torah is not necessarily literal. Hence the meat of this prohibition may come from a grown animal and the milk may be from a different animal family than the kid. Rather the Torah often speaks of a typical case where idolaters actually cooked the kid in its mother’s milk. The reader may ask, “How does one know whether the verse is literal or open to interpretation?” The oral law, referenced in the Talmud and other sources, provides this answer.
Halacha
The author will present a number of rulings in Halacha from the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh Deah Chapter 87) and then compare them to the above rationales as follows:
- Type of animal and milk (ibid. 3).
- Cooking (ibid. 1).
- Prohibited for benefit (ibid. 1).
Type of Animal and Milk
Although there is a dispute in the Talmud, the Shulchan Aruch (ibid. 3) rules that this prohibition only applies to kosher domesticated animals (i.e. ovine and bovine families) both for the meat and milk. Hence this prohibition does not apply to kosher undomesticated animals (e.g. deer) and fowl (e.g. chicken) from a biblical standpoint. However the Shulchan Aruch (ibid.) rules that consumption of this mixture is prohibited by rabbinic decree but cooking and benefit are permitted (ibid.).
Although this article frequently mentions milk these prohibitions apply to any dairy product (e.g. butter or cheese) with meat (Shulchan Aruch 89:1 and Aruch Hashulchan 87:10).
Cooking
From a biblical viewpoint this prohibition only applies if the meat and milk are cooked together. Hence if the two, when cold, are salted or soaked together the prohibition of consumption is rabbinic (Baer Hetev ibid.1). Although not explicit in the Talmud the decisors of Halacha include frying, placing cold food into hot, or pouring hot food into cold in this prohibition (ibid.). However the Aruch Hashulchan (Ibid. 10-11) cites a dispute whether frying meat with dairy is a biblical or a rabbinic prohibition.
Noahides
Noahides are permitted to eat meat cooked with milk because this prohibition is not included in their 7 mitzvoth.
Punishment
The punishment for either cooking meat and milk or eating the result is lashes (Maimonides Laws of Forbidden Foods 9:1).
Comparison
Based upon these rulings the author will compare them against the above rationales.
| Rationale | Type of Animal | Cooking | Benefit | Noahides |
| Idolatry | √ | √ | √ | X |
| Unhealthy | X | ? | ? | X |
| Mixtures | ? | ? | √ | √ |
| Negative Forces | √ | √ | √ | √ |
| Cruelty | ? | X | X | X |
| Gluttony | ? | ? | X | X |
Idolatry
Although this prohibition may be linked to idolatrous practices (i.e. cooking meat with milk of domesticated animals as a fertility rite) it is not idolatry otherwise the penalty for transgressing would be capital punishment by stoning instead of lashes. In addition Noahides would not be permitted to cook meat with milk if this practice were truly idolatrous because they are also forbidden to worship idols (Maimonides Laws of Kings 9:2). However they are permitted to eat meat with milk and are not required to follow the other dietary laws of the Torah except for eating a limb or flesh from a live animal (ibid. 10-13). By contrast the prohibition of benefit of this mixture bears resemblance to idolatry (Maimonides Laws of Idolatry 7:2).
Unhealthy
If health concerns were a rationale for this prohibition then it should apply to milk with undomesticated animals as well. In addition the prohibition should apply whether cooked or soaked. Even if the mixture is unhealthy for consumption it does not explain why benefit is prohibited because the mixture could be used as fodder. Furthermore the prohibition should apply to Noahides if the mixture is not suitable for humans because, “Hashem good to all and His mercies are on all His works (Psalms 145:9).”
Mixtures
The rationale of forbidden mixture as explained by the Sefer HaChinuch covers the 4 points of the above table. Specifically the Torah forbids the mixture of cooking meat and milk of domesticated animals just as the Torah prohibits the mixing of seeds in a vineyard. In addition both mixtures are prohibited from benefit for Israelites and permitted for Noahides. However this approach does not explain the details of the prohibition (i.e. only domesticated animals and cooking).
Negative Forces
Building on the above explanation of forbidden mixtures the Zohar addresses the specifics of the prohibition (i.e. only domesticated animals and cooking). The domesticated animals allude to the negative forces associated with the goat and cooking provides a strong means of combing these negative forces rather than soaking or salting. The association with the goat is only a partial explanation because other meat (e.g. cow or sheep) is also prohibited with milk.
The mother represents the Shechinah which acts a protecting and nurturing mother of the Israelites. Hence combining these forces is injurious to the soul of an Israelite and therefore the Torah prohibits benefit from this mixture to distance them from this prohibition. Since Noahides are not bound by the dietary laws of the Torah the affect on their soul is not significant. However they may observe these laws on a voluntary basis.
Cruelty
Although the rationale of cruelty provides a moral lesson for this prohibition it does not explain the above 4 details. The biblical prohibition of meat with milk does not apply to undomesticated kosher animals either in terms of the meat or milk. By contrast cruelty to animals applies to both domesticated and domesticated animals. In addition the biblical prohibition only applies to cooking meat with milk. If the prohibition involves cruelty it would not matter whether the mixture was cooked or combined when cold.
Although slaughtering the mother animal and its offspring on the same day is prohibited by the Torah, if a person transgressed he may eat the meat of either animal (Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah 16:3). However there are some who rule that one may not eat from the second animal until the next day so as not to benefit from the transgression. By contrast in the case of cooking meat with milk the result is permanently forbidden.
If cruelty were an issue then Noahides could be included in this prohibition because they are prohibited from eating meat from a live animal. Appendix 3 provides the details of this prohibition.
Gluttony
Although the rationale of gluttony provides a moral lesson for this prohibition it does not explain the above 4 details. The biblical prohibition of meat with milk does not apply to undomesticated kosher animals either in terms of the meat or milk. In addition the prohibition only applies if the meat is cooked with milk. However overindulgence applies to all kosher food whether cooked or not. In addition the mixture should not be prohibited from benefit because the owner could feed his animals with this mixture to avoid gluttony. Furthermore the prohibition should apply to Noahides to avoid gluttony.
Conclusion
This article examined the prohibitions of meat with milk (i.e. consuming, benefit, and cooking) to explore possible rationales for this law. The author initially surveyed a number of classical explanations and analyzed the text of the verses for these prohibitions and the preceding and following verses to establish context. In addition the author compared the rationales to details in Halacha to determine the best fit.
In the opinion of the author the explanation of the Zohar of negative forces produced by the cooking of meat with milk provides a compelling rationale for these prohibitions. This rationale is supported by the verses of the Torah and details of Halacha. In this manner an Israelite can avoid barriers from Hashem and strive for holiness as the Torah states (Deuteronomy 14:21), “You are a holy people to Hashem, your G-d. You shall not cook a kid in its mother’s milk”.
Appendix 1 – First Fruits
This appendix provides a brief summary of the laws of the first fruits based upon Maimonides Mishneh Torah (Laws of First Fruits Chapter 2).
Bringing of Fruit
Law 1 – “It is a positive commandment from the Torah to bring first fruits to the Temple. Therefore this commandment only applies while the Temple is standing and only for fruit grown in Israel as the verse Exodus 23:29), states: “You shall bring to the house of Hashem, your G-d the choicest first fruits of your land (Israel).”
Law 2 – “First fruits are brought only from the species which are cited by the Torah (Deuteronomy 8:8) as the praise of the land of Israel. They are wheat, barley, grapes, figs, pomegranates, olives, and dates.”
Law 3 – “This fruit must of the highest quality. Therefore one does not bring dates from the mountains or fruit from the valleys. Rather one brings dates from the valleys and fruit from the mountains, for they are of the highest quality.”
Law 6 – “The first fruits should not be brought before Shavuot, for the Torah (Exodus 23:16) calls this holiday as the harvest festival which is the first fruits of your labour … Similarly, the first fruits should not be brought after Chanukah because fruit that ripens after this time are considered as being of the next year.” These fruits would be given to the priest after Shavuot and typically before the end of Sukkot.
Ceremony of Bringing Fruit
Maimonides (ibid. Chapter 4) lists practices associated with the bringing of the fruit to Jerusalem as follows:
Law 1 – “When one brings the first fruits, it is necessary the fruit be raised up and down and moved in all four directions, that song be recited, a peace offering be brought, and the person remain in Jerusalem overnight.” These activities emphasize the connection between the person and Hashem. The raising and moving of the fruit indicates that Hashem is the master of heaven and earth and all 4 directions (Sukkah 37b).
Law 16 – “All of the inhabitants of the towns in a regional area gather in the central town of this area to ascend to Jerusalem as a group. The verse (Proverbs 14:28) teaches: The glory of the King (Hashem) is in a multitude of people.” In the morning, the leader calls out: Arise and let us ascend to Zion, to Hashem our G-d (Jeremiah 31:5). An ox with its horns glazed with gold leads the procession. A crown of olive branches is placed on its head, to publicize that the first fruits come from the seven species for which the land of Israel is praised. A flute plays before them until they arrive close to Jerusalem.”
Law 16 (continues) – “They walk the entire way and proclaim: “I rejoiced when it was told me: Let us go to the house of G-d (Psalms 122:1). When they arrived close to Jerusalem they sent emissaries to notify the inhabitants of Jerusalem. If they had some produce that was fresh and other produce that was dried, the fresh produce was placed on top. The leaders of the Israelites, the priests and Temple treasurers would go out from Jerusalem to greet them. The size of the welcoming party was proportionate to the number of people who come. When they entered the gates of Jerusalem, they begin declaring: “Our feet were standing in your gates, O Jerusalem” (ibid. 2).”
Law 17 – “All of the artisans in Jerusalem would stand in honour of them and greet them: “Our brethren, the inhabitants of so-and-so, you have come in peace.” They proceed through Jerusalem while the flute is sounded until they reach the Temple Mount. When they reach the Temple Mount, each one should carry the first fruits on his shoulders and say (Psalms 150:1): Hallelujah. Praise G-d in His holy place (the temple) until the conclusion of that psalm: May all souls praise You (Hashem).” They proceed through the Temple Mount until they reach the Temple Courtyard. When they reach the Temple Courtyard, the Levites open with song (Psalm 30): “I will exalt You, Hashem, for You have drawn me up and not let my enemies rejoice over me…”
This procession demonstrates the great joy of the harvest and thanking Hashem for the bounty.
Distribution and Consumption of Fruit
Maimonides (ibid. Chapter 3) discusses the distribution and consumption of the first fruits as follows:
Law 1 – “The first fruits are given to the priests on duty at that time. They divide it among themselves like Temple sacrifices.”
Law 2 – “The priests must consume these fruits in Jerusalem and not outside the walls of the city.”
These laws especially the procession to the temple with great celebration emphasize the connection between the Israelites and Hashem.
Appendix 2 – Mixed Seeds in a Vineyard
Maimonides (Laws of Forbidden Mixtures Chapter 5) explains that the prohibition of planting seeds in a vineyard involves planting two different types of seeds which is a prohibition in itself and an additional prohibition when planted in a vineyard. The laws follow:
Law 1 – “When a person sows two types of grain or vegetables together with grape seeds, he is liable for two sets of lashes (provided he was warned and witnessed by two men) one for violating the prohibition of planting mixed seeds (Leviticus 19:19) and the other planting them in a vineyard (Deuteronomy 22:9).”
Law 2 – A person does not receive lashes for sowing mixed seeds in a vineyard unless he sows two different types of seeds (2 types of grain, 2 types of vegetables, or 1 grain and 1 vegetable) and a grape seed. The grain involves wheat, barley, rye, oats and spelt. (This is a paraphrase of law 2 and not a direct quote.)
Maimonides (Laws of Forbidden Food Chapter 10) explains the details of the prohibition of consumption as follows:
Law 6 – “The prohibition of consumption or benefit applies whether they were sown by a Jew or a non-Jew or even if it grew on its own. The Torah (Ibid.) states: Lest the growth of the seed which you plant and the produce of the vineyard become forbidden (literally hallowed (meaning set apart and forbidden).”
In this manner the prohibitions of planting and consumption are distinct and not dependent on each other.
Law 8 – “The biblical prohibitions of planting and consumption only apply when the mixture was planted in Israel. If planted in the Diaspora the prohibitions of planting and consumption are by rabbinic decree.”
Appendix 3 – Eating Meat from a Live Animal
Maimonides (Laws of Kings Chapter 9) discusses the prohibition for Noahides of eating meat from a live animal. The Talmud (Sanhedrin 59b) derives this law from the Torah (Genesis 9:4), “But (אך), you shall not eat meat with its soul (i.e. alive) and its blood”. Presumably this law prevents cruelty to animals.
Law 10 – “A Noahide is prohibited from eating a limb or flesh from a living creature, however he is permitted to eat blood from a living (or dead) creature.”
Law 11 – “The prohibition applies to a limb or flesh that is separated from either a domesticated animal or beast. However, it appears to me that a Noahide is not liable for eating a limb taken from a living bird.”
Although the verse seems to indicate that a Noahide may not consume the blood of a live animal, Maimonides does not agree with this interpretation (ibid. 10). Rather Maimonides follows the Talmud (ibid.) which explains that the verse refers to the type of animal included in this prohibition, namely that creeping animals are excluded from this prohibition. The Talmud derives this exclusion from Genesis 9:4 and explains that expression “its blood” indicates that the prohibition pertains to animals whose blood is deemed separate from their flesh. This excludes these creeping animals, whose blood is deemed part of their flesh. These creeping animals may be small mammals (e.g. weasel, mouse, and mole from Leviticus 11:29) or lizards and the like.
