Forbidden Relationships – Overview

Introduction

The Torah (Leviticus 18:6-18) records a number of forbidden relations involving incest. These prohibitions follow the dictates of the Torah for morality and holiness. Rashi (on Leviticus 19:2) notes that the exhortation of the Torah (ibid.), “You shall be holy” directly follows the law of forbidden relations in chapter 18 of Leviticus. In addition the Torah (ibid. 20:7) commands the Israelites to be holy and then proceeds to list the punishments for transgressing these prohibitions.

The offspring of any of these forbidden relations is termed as illegitimate (in Hebrew ממזר) and may not marry a regular Israelite based upon Deuteronomy 23:3, “An illegitimate person shall not enter the assembly of Hashem (in marriage).” The Shulchan Aruch Even HaEzer Chapter 4 codifies these laws as definition (ibid. 13) and prohibition (ibid. 1).  By contrast, a child born out of wedlock but not though incest is not illegitimate and may marry as regular Israelite. 

Although the Torah in Chapter 18 of Leviticus records other forbidden relations (e.g. bestiality or between males) this article focuses on those between man and woman because the former do not lead to procreation.    

Rationale

The Torah does not explain why some relations are forbidden (e.g. nephew with an aunt) and some permitted (e.g. uncle with a niece). Nachmanides (Leviticus 18:6) comments that the Torah for the most part does not provide a rationale for prohibitions. At a basic level Nachmanides explains that these laws are decrees from Hashem and must be accepted as divine wisdom.

However Nachmanides acknowledges that one may attempt to find rationales for these laws. For example he quotes Maimonides (Guide for the Perplexed 3:49) who explains that these laws limit excessive marital relations or promiscuity. Otherwise a person with frequent access to these relatives could be led astray. However Nachmanides is not satisfied with this approach because the Torah permits polygamy and does not set a limit for the number of wives a man may marry except for a king (Deuteronomy 17:17). In addition for each of the incestuous relations the Torah applies the punishment of excision (ibid. 29) which may involve premature death or severe retribution in the world to come. Hence Nachmanides concludes that the Torah forbade these relations because the offspring will be spiritually tainted.

In summary the different forms of incest may lead to:

  • Biological defects (Appendix 1 discusses this medical aspect).
  • Dishonour of parents, uncles, or aunts (as shown in the following table).
  • Strife in the marriage or family (as shown in the following table).

Due to the length of this topic the author has divided this analysis into two articles on this web site: “Forbidden Relations – Overview” and “Forbidden Relations – Specifics”. This article provides an overview of this topic.

Analysis

Prohibition – Summary

The following table lists the different forms of incest with the related verse in Chapter 18 of Leviticus and primary rationale(s) for the prohibition.

IncestVerseRationale
Mother7Biological Defect, Honour (Direct)
Father’s Wife8Honour (Direct)
Sister (Biological)9Biological Defect
Daughter and Granddaughter10Biological Defect
Sister (Marriage)11Biological Defect
Aunt (Paternal)12Honour (Indirect)
Aunt (Maternal)13Honour (Indirect)
Aunt (Marriage)14Honour (Indirect)
Daughter in Law15Honour (Direct)
Sister in Law (Brother’s Wife)16Conflict
Mother and Daughter17Honour and conflict
Two Sisters18Conflict

The honour refers to honour due to parents.

The incestuous relations of the above table may be classified as follows:

  • Blood relation (i.e. mother, biological sister, daughter, and aunt whether paternal or maternal).
  • Through marriage (all others).

Blood Relative

This form of incest does not depend upon marriage meaning that if the son or daughter was conceived out of wedlock the prohibitions apply.  

Based Upon Marriage

The other forms of incest are conditional upon marriage meaning that if the man was intimate outside of marriage the prohibitions do not apply from the Torah. These relations may be classified as:

  • Mother – daughter and other offspring.
  • Wife – of father, uncle, brother, and son. 
  • Two sisters

Maimonides (Laws of Forbidden Relations 2:7) writes, “When a person marries a woman her close relatives become forbidden to him as follows:

  1. Her mother.
  2. Mother’s mother.
  3. Father’s mother.
  4. Daughter.
  5. Daughter’s daughter.
  6. Son’s daughter.
  7. Sister.

The first six prohibitions are permanent meaning even if this woman dies or is divorced from the husband. By contrast the last prohibition does not apply if the woman dies. The first three correspond to older generations while the next three relate to younger generations. It is interesting to note that that prohibitions 2-3 at a biblical level do not apply to a man’s mother. However prohibitions 5-6 apply to the father’s daughter. In the opinion of the author a man would not be as passionate or intrigued with relatives from his mother compared to those of his wife.     

Appendix 2 provides details for these prohibitions. 

In certain cases the rabbis have extended these prohibitions if the relation started outside of marriage.

Punishment – Summary

The following table lists the different forms of incest, verse number for punishment in Chapter 20 of Leviticus, and the actual punishment from the court, if there were witnesses who warned the transgressor and witnessed the act. Otherwise the punishment is through the hands of heaven by excision which could lead to an early death of the transgressor or death of their children.     

IncestVersePunishment
Mother11 (Derivation)Stoning
Father’s Wife11Stoning
Sister (Biological)17Lashes
Daughter and Granddaughter14 (Derivation)Burning
Sister (Marriage)11Lashes
Aunt (Paternal)19Lashes, Die childless
Aunt (Maternal)19Lashes
Aunt (Marriage)20Lashes
Daughter in Law12Stoning
Sister in Law (Brother’s Wife)21Lashes, Die childless
Mother and Daughter14Burning
Two SistersNo verseLashes

In the opinion of the author the rationale for the prohibition of these relationships is related to the type of punishment applied by the Torah (death by stoning, or fire, or lashes).

Court Action

For all of these punishments the transgressor must be warned by two men, witnessed by two men (the same as the men who warned him or others), and tried by a Sanhedrin of 23 judges for capital punishment (Sanhedrin 2a). By contrast a court of 3 is sufficient to apply lashes (ibid.). The Talmud (Makkot 7b) comments that capital punishment was rarely applied in Israel and states, “A Sanhedrin that executes a transgressor once in 7 years is characterized as a destructive tribunal. Rabbi Elazar ben Azarya says: This categorization applies to a Sanhedrin that executes a transgressor once in 70 years.” Since the Sanhedrin would subject the testimony to exacting scrutiny, it was extremely rare for an accused to be executed.

Although the Torah assigns capital punishment for certain transgressions the Talmud (Sanhedrin 45a) states that the method should be as human as possible based upon the verse (Leviticus 19:18), “You shall love your fellow as yourself”. 

Stoning

In the opinion of the author the Torah assigns capital punishment of stoning in cases of incest that involve disrespect of parents (i.e. mother, father’s wife, and daughter in law). The Sefer HaChinuch cites this reason for these first two prohibitions (Mitzvoth #190 and 191).

In addition the Torah (ibid. 20:9) cites the punishment of stoning for cursing a father or mother and then proceeds to list the punishments for different forbidden relationships (e.g. father’s wife) thus connecting stoning to disrespect of parents. In particular the Midrash (Numbers Rabbah 9:7) suggests that a son born of an incestuous or adulterous relationship may curse the suspected lover and like his adopted father not realizing that the former is in fact his biological father.

The Torah uses the expression, “Their blood is upon them” for incest with a father’s wife (Leviticus 20:11) and a daughter in law (ibid. 12) but does not indicate the form of capital punishment. The Talmud (Sanhedrin 66a) concludes that this expression means death by stoning through exegesis. The Torah (ibid. 27) clearly states that one who practices the rites of Ov or Yidoni shall be stoned. Then the verse adds the expression, “Their blood is upon them”.  Since the Torah links this expression to stoning it may be applied to other transgressions indicated by this expression.

Method

Maimonides (Laws of Sanhedrin 15:1) details the method of stoning as follows, “The place of execution was two storeys high (i.e. 6 amot which is about 3 meters or 10 feet). The convicted ascends there with his hands tied, together with his witnesses. One of the witnesses pushes him from behind at his thighs until he falls over and lands on his heart. If he does not die after this fall, the witnesses pick up a stone that is so large it requires two people to carry it. The second witness lets go and the first casts the stone on the heart of the convicted. If he dies they have fulfilled their obligation. If not, he should be stoned by others.”

Burning

In the opinion of the author the punishment of burning may indicate either misplaced passion or lust since these prohibitions involve a wife and her line (e.g. daughter, granddaughter, mother, and mother’s mother).

In addition incest with a biological daughter (e.g. from the father whether born in or out of wedlock) is also punishable by burning even though she may also curse her father for incest. In the opinion of the author a son is more likely to curse a parent than a daughter because in general men are more aggressive than women and are inclined to fight as the Talmud (Kiddushin 2b) states, “It is the way of a man to wage war and it is not the way of a woman to wage war.”   

Maimonides (Laws of Sanhedrin 15:3) details the method of burning as follows. ”The convicted is placed in fertilizer until his knees. A firm cloth is placed within a soft cloth and are wound around his neck. The two witnesses are positioned on either side and each one of them pulls the cloths toward himself until the convicted opens his mouth. Tin, lead, and the like are melted down and then poured into his mouth. The molten metal descends and burns his innards.”

Lashes

If the offense is not liable to capital punishment then the Torah assigns lashes to the forbidden relations (Maimonides Laws of Forbidden Relations 1:7). 

Prohibition for Noahides

Although the prohibitions of incest for Noahides are not explicit in the Torah the Talmud (Sanhedrin 58a-b) derives them from verses in Genesis. Maimonides (Laws of Kings 9:6), based upon the Talmud Sanhedrin (ibid.) lists the prohibitions of incest for Noahides as follows:

  • Father’s wife (Genesis 2:24). “Therefore, a man shall leave his father and mother and cling to his wife to become one flesh.”
  • Mother (ibid.).
  • Maternal sister (ibid. 20:12). Abraham said to Abimelech king of the Philistines about Sarah, “She is indeed my sister, the daughter of my father, though not of my mother; and became my wife.

Genesis 2:24

At a literal level the former verse tells a man to leave his parents, marry, and begin a household. The Talmud (ibid. a) applies this verse to incest prohibitions for Noahides. The father refers to his wife even if she is divorced or widowed from her husband. The mother refers to a biological mother and therefore this incest applies to the son whether born in or out of wedlock.

Genesis 20:12

At a literal level this verse refers to Abraham’s discussion with Abimelech after the latter took Sarah for his future wife. Abraham said that Sarah was his sister and not his wife, fearing that servants of Abimelech may kill Abraham and take Sarah (Genesis 20:11). Hence Abimelech did not realize that Sarah was actually the wife of Abraham. Abraham explained that although his statement about Sarah was misleading it was not false because she was like his paternal sister (ibid. 12). The Talmud (ibid. b) explains that Abraham emphasized this relationship to teach that incest with a sister follows the maternal line.  

Rashi (Genesis 20:12) points out that Sarah was not his sister but a niece through his deceased brother Haran. However a nephew may be called a brother (an expression of kinsmanship ibid. 13:8) and therefore a niece may be called a sister.    

Hence only direct relations are forbidden to Noahides (i.e. father, mother, and sister) but not those of aunts, in laws, and two sisters. In the opinion of the author the Torah was concerned about the honour due to parents and some biological defects for Noahides. 

Conclusion

This article provides an outline of forbidden incestuous, either punishable by capital punishment or lashes, quoting the relevant verses in scripture. In addition the author provided a rationale for the different prohibitions by punishment as follows:

  • Stoning – honour of parents.
  • Burning – misplaced compassion or excessive desire (e.g. father-daughter or mother-daughter relationships).
  • Lashes – indirect honour of parents and conflict.     

The objective of these prohibitions is to maintain the holiness of the Israelites as the verse states (Leviticus 20:7), “You shall sanctify yourselves and be holy, for I am Hashem, your G-d.”

Appendix 1 – Health Risks

Consanguineous marriage (i.e. marriage between close relatives) poses pregnancy complications and health risks. It increases the likelihood of birth defects, genetic disorders, and intellectual disabilities in children. Babies are at risk of inheriting rare, severe conditions, resulting in elevated infant mortality and developmental delays. Mothers face an increased risk of miscarriage and stillbirth. For these reasons most Western governments prohibit these unions.

In particular a marriage a between an uncle or aunt and their niece or nephew may lead to health risks to the offspring and are prohibited by law in some countries. However the Torah permits a marriage between an uncle and niece which implies that the risk is not great. 

The author found the following link informative:

https://www.readytobemom.com/en/blog/pregnancy-complications-from-marrying-relatives/

Appendix 2 – Seven Women

Maimonides (Laws of Forbidden Relations 2:7) writes, “If the husband has relations with one of these 7 women during the lifetime of his wife, both he and she are executed by burning.”  However If he has relations with one of these 6 women (i.e. excluding the sister) after the wife’s death, they are liable for excision but not executed by the court (ibid. 8). Other Talmud authorities (e.g. Rashi, Ramban, and Rashba) dispute this ruling and opine that after the wife’s death the prohibition applies but not excision.   

Both base their opinions on Leviticus 20:14, “A man who takes a woman and her mother it is evil counsel. They shall burn him and them (ואתהן) in fire.” The word ואתהן implies both of them (i.e. woman and mother). However a literal interpretation is not tenable because the man’s wife did not commit any transgression (Rashi on Sanhedrin 76a). Hence the verse indicates that a full punishment is applied when both are living (i.e. woman and her mother).  The disagreement relates to the exemption from punishment (i.e. capital punishment or even excision).   

Maimonides further explains (ibid. 2:11), ”However if a man engages in promiscuous relations with a woman, the seven relatives mentioned above are not forbidden to him according to Torah Law.” The Talmud (Yevamot 97a) explains that these prohibitions or punishments are written in the Torah as taking (e.g. Leviticus 18:18 and 20:14) which indicates marriage. Hence if the initial relation was promiscuous these prohibitions do not apply from the Torah.

Maimonides (ibid.) continues, “Nevertheless, the Sages prohibited anyone who had promiscuous relations with a woman from marrying one of these seven relatives during the promiscuous woman’s lifetime. (After her death the prohibition does not apply). The rationale is that the promiscuous woman will come to visit her relatives. He will thus enter into solitude with her. Since he is familiar with her, we fear that they will transgress and thus he will engage in relations with a forbidden woman.”

Maimonides (ibid.) writes, “Even if a man is merely suspected of relations with a woman he should not marry one of her relatives until this suspected woman died.”However Maimonides (commentary on Mishna Yevamot 11:1) states that this suspicion must be verified.  

Maimonides (ibid.) limits this prohibition as follows, “If he married a relative of the suspected woman he need not divorce her.” The sages set this law as a fence around the Torah (Avot 1:1) and did not rule that this marriage be dissolved.   

Hence this prohibition is not symmetrical in that it begins with a marriage and becomes a prohibition through an affair with these 7 women. However if a man would have an affair with a woman he could marry one of these 7 women from Torah law. In the former case marriage is not possible with the other women since the prohibition of excision applies.    

The same reasoning applies to the prohibition of a son with his father’s wife and a father with his son’s wife. In both cases the prohibition starts through marriage and not through an affair.    

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *